It’s not even Thanksgiving yet, and our TVs are already full of Christmas movies. Those holiday classics that feel like old friends back to visit and make our homes and hearts brighter. But this year, as I started to make my mental list of all of the movies I need to make sure to watch, I began to think about why I love each and every one. Because the ones we all love touch us in ways that are deeper than laughter and entertainment. They poignantly reveal something important about the human condition: a lesson that is happily reinforced in this most magical time of year. So, as I began to catalogue these festive teachings, I started to think about the money and meaning conversations that I am privileged to have with clients. And then it hit me: these wondrous classics reinforce so many of those things that make life meaningful; when we focus on them, our lives get richer. And isn’t a richer, more meaningful life the goal? With that purpose, let’s highlight what some of our favorite Christmas classics teach us.
The Grinch: The power of experiences vs. things
It’s a toss-up between the Grinch and Ebenezer Scrooge as to who is the most narcissistic holiday movie character. The Grinch hates Christmas because he hates joy, community and happiness. Finally, determined to replace Who joy with misery, he steals all of Whoville’s presents, along with the Christmas roast beast. But to his complete and utter shock, his dastardly deeds do not ruin Christmas at all; the Whos do not need presents to make them happy. Being with each other makes them happy.
While I am sure the Grinch did not read academic studies on the link between experiences and happiness, had he done so, he would have understood the foolishness of his plan. In their book, Happy Money, authors Elizabeth Dunn and Michael Norton highlighted several of these studies that all came to the same conclusion. Happy spending is focused on experiences and community (doing great things with great people) rather than buying things. What is interesting is how societally counterintuitive that is. Media sells the idea that happiness is driving the expensive car, lounging in the plush pool house, wearing the expensive watch while drinking the exclusive bourbon. But, scientifically, none of that matters nearly as much as who is riding, lounging or drinking with you. The Grinch stole the stuff, but he could not steal the spirit. So, lesson one, taught to us by our green and hairy friend: spending our money on great people doing great things together will lead to a richer life than buying stuff.
Fred Claus: Generosity defeats the destructive power of comparison
On to my daughter Lauren’s favorite Christmas movie: Fred Claus. Fred is Santa’s brother and spends a lifetime in misery comparing himself to his famous sibling. The movie does a very good job of showing what it feels like to have the world’s most famous saint as a brother, including an awesome scene of a support group of less famous siblings that includes Stephen Baldwin, Frank Stallone and Roger Clinton. Eventually, Fred needs to step in for his injured brother to save Christmas and learns that the joy that comes from selfless generosity defeats the misery of comparison. And the movie also delivers the emotionally resonant line: “There’s no naughty kids, Nick. They’re all good kids.”
Again, the academic studies provide strong evidence supporting Fred’s evolution. One of the scientifically greatest destroyers of happiness is comparison. In a 2012 study by Card, Mas, Moretti and Paz, the authors proved that job satisfaction materially decreased when the participants learned what other employees were making. Nothing else changed: their own pay, culture, working conditions, etc. But simply adding comparative information had a severe impact on job satisfaction.
A much more interesting 1995 study was published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology focusing on silver and bronze Olympic medal winners. The researchers, Madey and Gilovich, studied the facial expressions of silver and bronze medal winners on the podium after their events. Their study, and follow-up research, conclusively showed that the third-place bronze medalists were materially happier than their more accomplished second-place silver medalist competitors. The reason: silver medalists unfavorably compared themselves to the only person who bested them; the bronze winners compared themselves to all of the non-medalists.
So, what can we take from Fred Claus? The research is compelling. Stop making yourself miserable by comparing your situation to those you follow on Insta, to your neighbors, to your siblings (your own Saint Nicks) or to your co-workers. Instead, spend your time generously making others’ lives a little better. That is the recipe for a richer life that does not need to be concerned with riches.
Four Christmases: The power of purpose
Every Christmas, Brad and Kate tell their families (both are children of divorce and therefore each have two separate families; together they have four families, hence the title) that they are on a mission trip feeding the poor and will not be able to attend the family holiday festivities. What Brad and Kate are really doing is relaxing on the beach away from commitments, obligations, embarrassment and general family chaos. Unfortunately, as they are trying to board a plane in San Francisco to Fiji, they not only get fogged in, but a television crew captures their ordeal. Their families, having seen them, guilt them into attending four separate Christmases. While we clearly empathize with Brad and Kate given the general insanity of their families, the day causes the two of them to understand that their breezy, carefree life lacks meaning and purpose. At the end of the movie (in a one-year flash-forward), Brad and Kate have a more purposeful life committed to each other and their daughter.
Again, the social science supports the movie’s lessons. In a 2013 study in the Journal of Positive Psychology, Baumeister, Vohs, Aaker and Garbinsky found that stress and meaning were positively rather than negatively correlated. Specifically, the study found that a meaningful life was not necessarily a comfortable life. Things that demand responsibility, sacrifice and concern while adding momentary challenges add significance to life. Also, in a 1999 study authored by Sheldon and Elliot in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, the authors found that meaning and fulfillment correlated positively with difficult goals aligned with purpose and values rather than simple goals easily achieved.
So, what can we learn from Brad and Kate other than not to get into a jump-jump with our niece or into a cage match with our lunatic brothers? Life is richer when we add the stress of difficult goals that can be meaningfully achieved. And happiness sometimes comes from the stress of familial chaos.
It’s a Wonderful Life: The true meaning of rich
Every year I do a presentation around the holidays that starts by asking the audience a question: would you rather be George Bailey or Mr. Potter? In perhaps the most revered holiday movie of all time, the protagonist, George Bailey, spends about two hours of the two-hour-and-ten-minute movie in misery: angry about potential unrealized. On the other hand, Mr. Potter spends most of the movie with a surface glee surrounding his wealth, greed and the misery he inflicts on George Bailey. But in the ten-plus years I have asked that question, the vast majority of voters want to be George Bailey, the person described by his brother Harry as the “richest person I know.” That “richness” is not measured in wealth; it’s measured in impact.
In my thirty-year career, I have met more Mr. Potters than George Baileys. It’s interesting that Potter is so vilified given that his actions and mindset are personifications of our culture and the financial services industry. Those who are most revered and envied are those who have the most wealth, not those who make the most impact. What is advertised is more money and more luxury rather than more generosity or selflessness. But what’s interesting to me is that what is believed is not what is true. What the researchers have unanimously found, as have I is that Harry Bailey had it exactly right—impact and generosity is what leads to happiness, not the selfishness required to build a more robust balance sheet. Those I have found to live the richest lives measure their success with the lives they have touched, not the dollars they have.
So, what can we learn from George Bailey and Mr. Potter? Lives of significance, fulfillment and happiness start with purpose: Who do I want to impact? How can I positively influence the lives of those I care about? What can I do to make the world a better place? There is a saying: whoever has the most toys at the end wins. Unfortunately, it’s a game where no one is there to cheer you on.